For 3D reconstruction and photogrammetry, the open-source Meshroom wins with its robust, customizable algorithms and compatibility with various tools. However, for SFF PC case enthusiasts seeking extraordinary airflow, RGB lighting, and high-capacity GPU support, Meshilicious scores high.
Key Differences Between Meshroom and Meshilicious
- User Base: Meshroom targets those into 3D printing, scanning, photogrammetry. Meshilicious is for PC builders, modders and enthusiasts.
- Creation: Meshroom stems from an academia-industry partnership, Meshilicious is a product of Lian Li and NCASE’s joint venture.
- Capabilities: Meshroom supports 3D reconstruction, camera tracking. Meshilicious supports high-capacity GPUs with excellent airflow.
- Customization: Meshroom integrates into render farm systems, adjustments by studio pipeline. Meshilicious allows hardware modification with mATX mainboard, radiator, PSU repositioning.
| Comparison | Meshroom | Meshilicious |
|---|---|---|
| Type | 3D Reconstruction Software | PC Case |
| Manufacturing Method | Open Source | Joint Venture: Lian Li and NCASE |
| Main Features | 3D Reconstruction, Camera Tracking | Mesh panels, RGB illumination, Large GPU support |
| Addons and plugins | Blender, Maya, Houdini plugins, CCTag library, PopSIFT | Included PCI-E 3.0 Riser card, Preinstalled 240MM Water Cooler |
| Compatibility | Windows and OSX/Linux | Mini ITX, mATX Mainboard support, RTX A4000, RTX 3060 Ti, 3070 GPUs |
| Specific Applications | 3D printing, 3D scanning, Photogrammetry | Compact Home PC, Custom modification, Gaming |
| Resource Management | Can use video input, aimed at real-time 3D capture | Dual-storage design, Up to 64GB of DDR4 Memory |
| Additional Info (Use & Performance) | Targets rough, textured items, Advised to coat glossy objects for better results | Can house the RTX 3090 10GB GRAPHICS CARD, CPU options without compromising streaming performance |
| Future Potential | Extended photogrammetry for large-scale projects like CT scanned human body | Upgradable, Plug and Play with an Operating System |
What Is Meshroom and Who’s It For?
Meshroom is free open-source 3D reconstruction software based on the AliceVision framework, which provides robust 3D reconstruction and camera tracking algorithms. This unique software emerged from the collaboration between academia and industry, marrying research with real-world applications. It’s specifically designed for integration into render farm systems and studio pipelines. Meshroom is ideal for anyone engaged in 3D printing, 3D scanning, and photogrammetry – be they hobbyists, professionals in robotics, medicine, video games, movies, or geomatics.
Pros of Meshroom
- Robust, quality algorithms in production
- Allows for customization in studio pipelines
- Able to handle large-scale projects like CT scanned human body
- Availability for both Windows and OSX/Linux users
Cons of Meshroom
- Limited effectiveness on glossy or transparent objects
- Usage for publication requires citation
What Is Meshilicious and Who’s It For?
Brought into life by Ssupd (Sunny Side Up Design) – a teaming of Lian Li and NCASE, Meshilicious is a Small Form Factor (SFF) PC case lending an internal capacity of 14.6 litres. Meshilicious is the first PC case from the Ssupd assembly line, sporting distinctive mesh panels and integrated RGB illumination, packing a punch of functionality within a compact, stylish design. If you’re a fan of high-performing systems with impressive visual aesthetics, this mini-ITX case built for up to 4-slot GPUs is especially for you.
Pros of Meshilicious
- Exceptional airflow and integrated RGB illumination
- Compact yet supports large 4-slot GPUs
- Comes preinstalled with a 240MM Water Cooler
- Flexible dual-storage design
Cons of Meshilicious
- Minor drawbacks in size restrictions for some components
- Challenges in DIY modifications
So Meshroom or Meshilicious: Who Steals the Show?
After extensive examination of both Meshroom and Meshilicious, let’s dip our feet into the final decision – which technology should take pride of place in your toolbox?
AR/VR Constructors and Hobbyists
For those living and breathing AR/VR from initial development stages up to intricate rendering, Meshroom shines brighter than its counterpart. It justifies its dominance with a longstanding pedigree in academic-industrial collaboration, dense suite of tools like Maya and Houdini plugins, and ubiquity available for both Windows and OSX/Linux users. Moreover, Meshroom’s templated workflow ensures smooth sailing amidst the choppy seas of 3D photogrammetry.
3D Printing and Scanning Fans
Embarking on 3D printing or scanning adventures? Meshroom is your go-to technology. Standing tall above its rival, it steadies the rudder with real-time 3D capture capabilities using prevalent devices like Microsoft Kinect. And remember: Meshroom caters to photogrammetry, even offering extended photogrammetry for ambitious projects like CT scanned human body replicas.
Compact PC Assemblers
For custom PC builders with a fondness for compact designs, Meshilicious claims its foothold. The Ssupd offering manifests as a mini-ITX case with astonishingly vast internal capacity – 14.6 litres, in fact! Furthermore, Meshilicious indulges desires for spectacular aesthetics with four distinctive mesh panels and integrated RGB illumination. And did we mention? It even houses the towering RTX 3090 Graphics Card – a feat few compact cases can execute.
If you’re traversing the labyrinth of 3D reconstruction or sailing on 3D scanning shores, Meshroom is the ace up your sleeve. However, for compact PC architects aiming for form balanced with function, Meshilicious rises as a radiant champion.
